Episode 29: Live Halloween Investigation at the Haunted Cottonwood Inn

Uncut footage reveals new insights into the Roen family’s mysterious past

On Halloween weekend 2024, Josh and Tammy returned to the Cottonwood Inn in Empire, Michigan, inviting a group of guests to participate in a live paranormal investigation. This uncut video captures the raw and unfiltered experiences of the night, as each participant encounters the eerie energies that permeate the historic inn.

The Cottonwood Inn, originally the Roen family farmhouse built around 1900, has a storied and somber history. The Roen brothers—Andrew, Benhart, and Severt—lived reclusive lives within its walls. Severt vanished in 1977 and was never found, while Andrew and Benhart died under mysterious circumstances in 1985. Their deaths, coupled with the discovery of hidden cash and antiques, have fueled decades of speculation and paranormal intrigue .

During this live investigation:

• Guests report personal experiences, including unexplained noises, sensations, and sightings.
• Tammy leads the group, guiding participants through the inn’s most active areas.
• The atmosphere intensifies, setting the stage for the subsequent séance that would challenge previous understandings of the Roen family’s story.

This episode serves as a prelude to the next, where a séance conducted by Tammy and the team unveils revelations that alter the narrative of the Cottonwood Inn’s haunted legacy.